Comedy shows that went off the boil Posted Sat Aug 19 15:54:03 BST 2000 by Mike McD

I nominate Ab Fab, Porridge and Roseanne. And my mother swears that Last of the Summer Wine was hilarious when it started all those years ago...


Subject: Re: Comedy shows that went off the boil [ Previous Message ]
Posted By Bent Halo on Sat Aug 19 17:24:10 BST 2000:

Room 101


Subject: Re: Comedy shows that went off the boil [ Previous Message ]
Posted By John! on Sat Aug 19 18:24:55 BST 2000:

Red Dwarf.


Subject: Re: Comedy shows that went off the boil [ Previous Message ]
Posted By Christopher Lyons on Sat Aug 19 18:38:51 BST 2000:

Fraiser has been crap recently, though the last episode currently broadcast was really good.


Subject: Re: Comedy shows that went off the boil [ Previous Message ]
Posted By John! on Sat Aug 19 19:17:25 BST 2000:

I think Season 7 of Frasier was very good myself. It's not *quite* up to the standards of Season 1-5, but still the best thing on television.

And as you say, the finale was wonderful.


Subject: Re: Comedy shows that went off the boil [ Previous Message ]
Posted By Justin on Sat Aug 19 20:16:30 BST 2000:

True confession: I actually remember enjoying Last Of The Summer Wine, round about 1980-82, I think, but I must have stopped watching it soon afterwards.

Only Fools & Horses was good till the end of series 6 (1989), but subsequently became a bit tired and obvious in its humour. (The only one I really like after that is the Stage Fright one from 91 with Phil Pope, and even that's based on the most slender quirk of a man who can't say the letter 'r'.)

One Foot remained good until the 1997 Christmas Special, where we think Margaret's died, except she hasn't. I don't have high hopes for the new series.

Come to think of it, there are only a handful of shows that stayed good right to the end:
Not The Nine O'Clock News
Cheers
Seinfeld

There are others, but usually only things that lasted two series (Fawlty Towers the most obvious example).


Subject: Re: Comedy shows that went off the boil [ Previous Message ]
Posted By Cornfed on Sat Aug 19 20:34:04 BST 2000:

Although a lot of people are probably going to disagree, but I'd add the League of Gentlemen to the list. First series, good, first episode of the second series, very promising, especially Papa Lazaru. After that, the show seemed to concentrate more on being 'dark' than actually funny. And it relyed too much on the Hale-&-Pace-exploding-animals-shock-factor.


Subject: Re: Comedy shows that went off the boil [ Previous Message ]
Posted By John! on Sun Aug 20 14:52:54 BST 2000:

Men Behaving Badly went off in its last few episodes.

South Park is now almost terrible.

And much as I hate to say it, I don't think The Simpsons is quite as superb as it used to be.


Subject: Re: Comedy shows that went off the boil [ Previous Message ]
Posted By Joe on Sun Aug 20 21:35:14 BST 2000:

>Although a lot of people are probably going to disagree, but I'd add the League of Gentlemen to the list. First series, good, first episode of the second series, very promising, especially Papa Lazaru. After that, the show seemed to concentrate more on being 'dark' than actually funny. And it relyed too much on the Hale-&-Pace-exploding-animals-shock-factor.
>
I agree, papa lazarou was the best thing about series two, whereas the charity shop women weren't.


Subject: Re: Comedy shows that went off the boil [ Previous Message ]
Posted By 1001 cleans a big big carpet on Mon Aug 21 01:18:37 BST 2000:

I nominate this thread. It's just not as good as it used to be.

Then again, maybe it never was...


Subject: Re: Comedy shows that went off the boil [ Previous Message ]
Posted By sheep on Mon Aug 21 09:25:22 BST 2000:

I agree The Simpsons is starting to lose it. Getting too self-referential, and using that as a joke too much (cf. "worst episode ever")

Viz comic, though the last edition improved over the previous, which was the poorest I can remember.

Shooting Stars, which was a good subversive game show for around half of it's first series.

Have I Got News For You which I'm sure used to be funny once.

and I also agree with the poster who's older relative thought Last of the SUmmer Wine used to be quite funny. When the beeb wheeled out an old episode as a tribute to Bill Owen when he died, it was obvious that there did used to be genuine, if still very soft and easy going, comedy in it.


Subject: Re: Comedy shows that went off the boil [ Previous Message ]
Posted By Barney on Mon Aug 21 10:08:22 BST 2000:

The Fast Show was good when it started but became almost unwatchably bad, and the third series of Father Ted wasn't much cop either.


Subject: Re: Comedy shows that went off the boil [ Previous Message ]
Posted By TJ on Mon Aug 21 12:17:28 BST 2000:

The Simpsons, definitely.
And One Foot In The Grave.


Subject: Re: Comedy shows that went off the boil [ Previous Message ]
Posted By Al on Mon Aug 21 16:46:35 BST 2000:

No way on The Simpsons. I'm afraid. Just saw 'Trash of the Titans' and watched 'Simpson Tide' the other night - two of the funniest I've seen. For me it's the self-referentiality that makes it funny etc. etc.


Subject: Re: Comedy shows that went off the boil [ Previous Message ]
Posted By Steve Berry on Mon Aug 21 17:07:38 BST 2000:

Any series which I liked before my mates did and, then, once they'd seen it and decided they liked it too, I went off.

Any comedy show before they started using synthesisers and sold out to a big label.

Any comedy show that wasn't presented in its entirely unexpurgated form with pre-title clocks, 'alternate' endings and director's commentary.

Oh, and TV Go Home. It's not as funny as it used to be before everyone got the joke.

Cheerio

Steve


Subject: Re: Comedy shows that went off the boil [ Previous Message ]
Posted By John! on Mon Aug 21 18:21:36 BST 2000:

I thought Trash of the Titans was a bit ropey.

And of the few new episodes I have seen (on video), they're just too...predictable and don't produce as many laughs as the classic seasons 2-8 (ish).

Still better than almost everything else on television, of course.


Subject: Re: Comedy shows that went off the boil [ Previous Message ]
Posted By ...for less than half a crown on Mon Aug 21 19:51:17 BST 2000:

This thread is DEFINITELY getting worse. Not like it was in the old days.


Subject: Re: Comedy shows that went off the boil [ Previous Message ]
Posted By Millman on Mon Aug 21 21:03:54 BST 2000:

The Mary Whitehouse Experience & Richard not Judy.....shame.


Subject: Re: Comedy shows that went off the boil [ Previous Message ]
Posted By John! on Mon Aug 21 21:06:35 BST 2000:

Casting Couch...

...oh no wait, that was shite from start to finish.


Subject: Re: Comedy shows that went off the boil [ Previous Message ]
Posted By Dr. Hackenbush on Tue Aug 22 00:11:59 BST 2000:

South Park went off the boil but is now simmering nicely - that Chinpokomon thing was great, if only for the parody Japanimation.
The most severe examples as far as I rememeber:
A Bit of Fry and Laurie final series (but still better than most BBC comedy).
Absolutely (unrecognisable)
I also remember Last of The Summer Wine being good, but then I was young and stupid when it came out.


Subject: Re: Comedy shows that went off the boil [ Previous Message ]
Posted By John! on Tue Aug 22 00:47:16 BST 2000:

I still reckon South Park is pretty terrible. It doesn't seem to have the impact it once did.

Now Babes in the Wood with Denise Van Outen. *That* had impact.


Subject: Re: Comedy shows that went off the boil [ Previous Message ]
Posted By Lee Mendham on Tue Aug 22 19:55:59 BST 2000:

Who Dares Wins started out well but soon got crappy.
On the other hand KYTV was much better than its radio predecessor Radio Active.


Subject: Re: Comedy shows that went off the boil [ Previous Message ]
Posted By Al on Tue Aug 22 19:59:16 BST 2000:

Controversial...


Subject: Re: Comedy shows that went off the boil [ Previous Message ]
Posted By Jon on Wed Aug 23 10:37:50 BST 2000:

They had different targets. RA did stuff about R4 that wouldn't translate well to TV.

CF. OTH/TDT.


Subject: Re: Comedy shows that went off the boil [ Previous Message ]
Posted By Goldilocks on Wed Aug 23 15:58:22 BST 2000:

I was gutted when Porridge went off the boil.


Subject: Re: Comedy shows that went off the boil [ Previous Message ]
Posted By Lee Mendham on Thu Aug 24 23:52:27 BST 2000:

The thing I disliked about Radio Active was that it didn't have the high-octane humour of The Burkiss Way.


[ Add Your Comment On This Subject ]
[ Add Your Comment Quoting Message ]