Dr Who/BBC Video Edge of Destruction Posted Fri Jun 2 18:30:41 BST 2000 by Paul

Has anyone bought the recent BBC video release of Dr Who 'Edge of Destruction' ?? I was wandering what exact "new" material from the pilot epsiode is included ? Someone mentioned it has a VT countdown clock ? Is there any additonal title sequence as I previously read somewhere ?


Subject: Re: Dr Who/BBC Video Edge of Destruction [ Previous Message ]
Posted By John! on Fri Jun 2 18:44:15 BST 2000:

I keep looking at it longingly in Smiths, but then realising there are other things I want slightly more.

I didn't buy The Invasion of Time either.

I'm so lame!


Subject: Re: Dr Who/BBC Video Edge of Destruction [ Previous Message ]
Posted By Anonymous on Mon Jun 5 11:02:11 BST 2000:

'The Edge Of Destruction' was a special 2-episode story, set entirely in the TARDIS, which had to be slung together and performed live on air because the sets weren't ready for the next story. It was the 3rd DW story, straight after the 1st Daleks one.


Subject: Re: Dr Who/BBC Video Edge of Destruction [ Previous Message ]
Posted By John! on Mon Jun 5 12:26:25 BST 2000:

Yes, I know.

I don't read DWM for nothing.


Subject: Re: Dr Who/BBC Video Edge of Destruction [ Previous Message ]
Posted By Anonymous on Mon Jun 5 13:09:03 BST 2000:

I'm sure you know.

I was just saying all that for the benefit of the other ladies and gentlemen, who may not have known.


Subject: Re: Dr Who/BBC Video Edge of Destruction [ Previous Message ]
Posted By John! on Mon Jun 5 17:22:49 BST 2000:

But there's no-one else in here.


Subject: Re: Dr Who/BBC Video Edge of Destruction [ Previous Message ]
Posted By Bent Halo on Mon Jun 5 23:33:18 BST 2000:

Oh yes there cocking well is.

The pilot differs in many respects, but the BBCV of 'An Unearthly Child' has been discontinued. This means (a)you can't verify changes if you don't have a copy, (b)second hand dealers are on to you.

The entrance into the TARDIS, you may note, is very odd given that it's pitch black and there is a lot of random noise and shouting. Some of the script differs, but largely it's a slower and less confident version of the first episode proper. Mind you, I haven't bought the tape to see if they've cut it down from the version shown on BBC2 in 1991. Should do really, given that I love 'Edge Of Destruction'.

Cuts are possible in Dr Who vids. 'The Romans' was chopped, albeit accidentally. There are so many different prints of early episodes, most of them messy re-cut foreign copies. Here the mistakes usually arise.

Anyone spotted other edits?


Subject: Re: Dr Who/BBC Video Edge of Destruction [ Previous Message ]
Posted By Jon on Tue Jun 6 06:56:24 BST 2000:

Since a lot of the early DW stuff was done live on air, chopping about with the copies will probably improve them.


Subject: Re: Dr Who/BBC Video Edge of Destruction [ Previous Message ]
Posted By John! on Tue Jun 6 13:07:35 BST 2000:

<sniff>

I don't have any of the First Season I don't think.

Or do I? I can't remember now.


Subject: Re: Major misapprehension! [ Previous Message ]
Posted By Gareth on Thu Jun 8 13:06:22 BST 2000:

FWIW, Doctor Who was *never ever* transmitted live - it was always recorded.

The urban myth that it was live seems to have gained currency because so many of the early stories contain dialogue fluffs, missed cues and so on that were never removed or reshot due to constraints of time and budget - remember, we're talking about the days when videotape editing meant physically cutting the tape with a razor blade!


Subject: Re: Dr Who/BBC Video Edge of Destruction [ Previous Message ]
Posted By John! on Thu Jun 8 18:14:56 BST 2000:

I'm going to miss Gary Gillatt.


Subject: Re: Dr Who/BBC Video Edge of Destruction [ Previous Message ]
Posted By Bent Halo on Thu Jun 8 23:27:39 BST 2000:

Garry Gillat

(laughs)

Shouldn't have shot my mouth off earlier. I've bought the vid of @edge Of Destruction'. Haven't got past the first show. Too busy.

I remember now that the 1991 repeat was cut down to remove said 'black-out' sequence before the final sequence. It's in the archive copy and is obviously a section which wasn't completed, because it was shot in real time and there were no visual effects ready.

Will comment later, unless people want to swap libellous stories about DWM/DWB editors, past and present. We can do.


Subject: Re: Dr Who/BBC Video Edge of Destruction [ Previous Message ]
Posted By John! on Fri Jun 9 17:38:57 BST 2000:

Are you then, Gary Russell?


Subject: Re: Dr Who/BBC Video Edge of Destruction [ Previous Message ]
Posted By No on Fri Jun 9 19:01:23 BST 2000:

For some reason I always wanted to see Edge of Destruction, because when I was younger I read that the Doctor attacks someone with scissors.
Looks a bit shit now though, to be honest.
I don't like DWM much either - don't you find it a bit, hmmm, so-so?


Subject: Re: Dr Who/BBC Video Edge of Destruction [ Previous Message ]
Posted By John! on Fri Jun 9 22:28:11 BST 2000:

No, not at all. It's got soul, and character. How many other sci-fi mags can claim that?

It's also incredibly well written and designed.


Subject: Re: Dr Who/BBC Video Edge of Destruction [ Previous Message ]
Posted By Bent Halo on Sat Jun 10 00:08:30 BST 2000:

>Are you then Gary Russell.

1992, the contents of his car boot. His merchandise was refused.


Subject: Re: Dr Who/BBC Video Edge of Destruction [ Previous Message ]
Posted By John! on Sat Jun 10 00:14:26 BST 2000:

Oooh, I say.


Subject: Re: Dr Who/BBC Video Edge of Destruction [ Previous Message ]
Posted By No on Tue Jun 13 18:19:14 BST 2000:

Hey, I used to read the Skaro fanzine - is that still going?


Subject: Re: Dr Who/BBC Video Edge of Destruction [ Previous Message ]
Posted By John! on Tue Jun 13 20:03:39 BST 2000:

I'm not sure.

Last time I saw it was about 1995.


Subject: Re: Dr Who/BBC Video Edge of Destruction [ Previous Message ]
Posted By Bent Halo on Mon Jun 19 19:27:33 BST 2000:

Last time I saw Skaro was issue 13. I think they all defected to a regular salary at DWM.

Which is agreta shame. Skaro was held in disdain by a lot of fans for no apparent reason. Even when I wasn't particularly paying attention to Who stuff, I'd always pick up a copy. It generally inspired me to dig vids out.

Much missed,.


Subject: Re: Dr Who/BBC Video Edge of Destruction [ Previous Message ]
Posted By TJ on Tue Jun 20 11:29:57 BST 2000:

Doctor Who may never have been transmitted live, but that didn't stop every bloody convention guest ever saying "oh it was all live then, you know" in response to any question displaying the vaguest semblance of intelligence.

And if you want a good, vibrant, thriving DW fanzine, go to http://www.stanley115.freeserve.co.uk/ - you won't regret it.


Subject: Re: Dr Who/BBC Video Edge of Destruction [ Previous Message ]
Posted By Bent Halo on Tue Jun 20 17:51:46 BST 2000:

'The Feast Of Steven' went out live, didn't it? Christmas Day 64, Hartnell pissed on air?


Subject: Re: Dr Who/BBC Video Edge of Destruction [ Previous Message ]
Posted By John! on Tue Jun 20 19:47:40 BST 2000:

No, believe it or not, that was planned.

Didn't they park the TARDIS in Liverpool?


Subject: Re: Dr Who/BBC Video Edge of Destruction [ Previous Message ]
Posted By Al on Tue Jun 20 22:52:06 BST 2000:

Sorry to skip back - I tried to post this last night but couldn't for some reason - but on the subject of fanzines what's DWB like these days? I dug out a couple of old ones recently and they were pretty good - a couple of excellent articles by Paul Cornell. It's gone all professional now hasn't it? And covers all TV SF? Is it any cop any more?


Subject: Re: Dr Who/BBC Video Edge of Destruction [ Previous Message ]
Posted By John! on Wed Jun 21 16:22:27 BST 2000:

It's now called Dreamwatch, and has been 'professional' for years and years. It covers everything, and is a bit rubbish.


Subject: Re: Dr Who/BBC Video Edge of Destruction [ Previous Message ]
Posted By Bent Halo on Wed Jun 21 18:45:01 BST 2000:

DWB's byline was to call itself a telefantasy mag with an emphasis on Dr Who, "obviously". Noticed the new issue had 300 words on the series.

Stinks to high heaven these days. Lost it after the 30th anniversary when the 'Dreamwatch' plan was being hatched. A far cry now from great Cornell articles like 'Dissent Is Good' and the 'Forgotten Era' article on pre-Sixties telefantasy.

Re:'Feast Of Steven'. But the toast to camera wasn't planned, was it? I;ve always read that the production crew were very embarassed by that, rather than the 'Z Cars' nonsense.

Never seen it obviously.


Subject: Re: Dr Who/BBC Video Edge of Destruction [ Previous Message ]
Posted By John! on Wed Jun 21 19:11:33 BST 2000:

Well, you're probably right, actually.

Bloody Hartnell.


[ Add Your Comment On This Subject ]
[ Add Your Comment Quoting Message ]