Stupid regions Posted Tue Apr 25 22:38:59 BST 2000 by Ben

Now I thought the area covered by BBC Midlands Today looked a stupid shape (and it does) but I've just seen the new corporate titles for "BBC North" (across Yorkshire, Lincolnshire and the North Midlands - catchy, eh?) Look North, and I have to say, what is the point of that? Yorkshire is just so different from Lincs or Nottingham (etc) so why do they come under the same region? Surely it would make more sense to put these areas under "East Midlands" or something - does anyone else know of any other regions that need a sort out?


Subject: Re: Stupid regions [ Previous Message ]
Posted By David Cobley on Wed Apr 26 11:37:01 BST 2000:

>Surely it would make more sense to put these areas under "East Midlands" or something?

There is an East Midlands region for the BBC based at Nottingham. It was split out of the Midlands Today region about 10 years ago (?) although kept looking the same until a couple of years ago when East Midlands Today took on a different look. I don't know if they hae adopted the corporate look yet, though.

I think the maps ae just trying either to grab as many possible viewers as "theirs" for the programme, or make sure that no viewer feels left out.


Subject: Re: Stupid regions [ Previous Message ]
Posted By Damian McCaughan on Wed Apr 26 19:57:38 BST 2000:

The transmitters for Lincolnshire also cover parts of Yorkshire - hence it coming under BBC North and YTV. To be fair, the Look North titles don't grab as much territory as the weather map! (And in the mid eighties the Leeds titles showed the entire north of England!)


Subject: Re: Stupid regions [ Previous Message ]
Posted By Andrew Bowden on Wed Apr 26 21:19:55 BST 2000:

>The transmitters for Lincolnshire also cover parts of Yorkshire - hence it coming under BBC North and YTV. To be fair, the Look North titles don't grab as much territory as the weather map! (And in the mid eighties the Leeds titles showed the entire north of England!)

Last time I saw North West Tonight, the weather map spread out as far as Middlesborough in the North East. Of course, they didn't put any symbols there. No, they were all in a very narrow band to the left of the screen.


Subject: Re: Stupid regions [ Previous Message ]
Posted By David Cobley on Wed Apr 26 21:47:38 BST 2000:

Every time Central decides to revamp its weather map it gets smaller and smaller. Or at least the bit of it that actually shows the region does, more of the country is shown (although not with symbols). The Central South region now seems ever so small on screen.


Subject: Re: Stupid regions [ Previous Message ]
Posted By Jase on Wed Apr 26 21:59:35 BST 2000:

Wooo! One more example of Carlton taking over the world perhaps?

I have noticed that Tyne Tees have started putting weather icons over Cumbria sometimes -- trying to get us used to it??


Subject: Re: Stupid regions [ Previous Message ]
Posted By george - [email protected] on Fri Apr 28 21:31:28 BST 2000:

The regions only look stupid because of overlap in transmitter coverage, and don't really exactly cover the stated areas.

Thus:

Carlton-LWT/Anglia: covers Hertfordshire, Parts of South Bedfordshire, Buckinghamshire and Southern Essex
Carlton(Central RIP)/Anglia: covers Northamptonshire, and parts of Cambridgeshire, Lincolnshire and Rutland.
and of course in South Lincolnshire you can recieve Central (Sorry, Carlton), Anglia and Yorkshire.

Anyway, this generally applies to analogue terrestrial viewers. Furthermore, since ITV and BBC seem to be single entites with only regional opt-outs for news and low-qaulity token programmes, then it is only a matter of time before these labels disappear.....


[ Add Your Comment On This Subject ]
[ Add Your Comment Quoting Message ]